Part 1 of 3

The Hours Behind the Bathroom Door

For nearly six months, my five-year-old daughter’s evening bath belonged entirely to my husband.

At first, I welcomed the arrangement. I worked three days a week as a landscape designer in Madison, Wisconsin, and although I loved being a mother more than anything else in my life, the hours between dinner and bedtime often left me worn thin. There were dishes in the sink, lunches to prepare, emails to answer, and a little girl who could turn brushing her teeth into a negotiation worthy of the United Nations.

My husband, Reed, presented bath time as his contribution.

“You handle everything else,” he told me one evening, carrying our daughter upstairs beneath one arm while she laughed and kicked her pajama-clad legs. “Let me take care of this.”

Our daughter, Maisie, was a quiet child with pale blond curls and thoughtful blue eyes. She collected smooth stones from the garden, slept with a stuffed rabbit named Juniper, and apologized whenever she believed she had taken up too much space. Reed called her his little shadow. In front of other people, he was patient and playful, the kind of father who crouched to her level when she spoke and remembered to bring extra snacks to the park.

Everyone trusted him.

So did I.

The first thing that troubled me was the amount of time they spent behind the bathroom door. A child’s bath should have lasted fifteen or twenty minutes, yet Reed and Maisie were often upstairs for more than an hour. I could hear the water running, stopping, and running again. Sometimes there were long stretches of silence.

Whenever I knocked, Reed gave the same answer.

“Almost finished.”

Then he would open the door twenty minutes later, smiling as if nothing were unusual.

Maisie never came out smiling.

She would be wrapped tightly in a towel, her shoulders hunched and her eyes fixed on the floor. Rather than chattering about toys or asking for a bedtime story, she climbed directly beneath her blankets and curled around Juniper.

One night, as I reached for the hair dryer, Maisie flinched so sharply that it nearly slipped from my hand.

“Sweetheart, it’s only me,” I said.

She stared at me for a moment, then whispered, “I’m tired.”

I sat beside her after she fell asleep, telling myself that children went through phases. Perhaps she had become afraid of water. Perhaps she was staying up too late. Perhaps Reed had invented a game that excited her so much that she exhausted herself.

There were plenty of innocent explanations.

The trouble was that none of them settled the feeling growing inside me.

A few evenings later, I found a damp washcloth tucked behind the laundry hamper. A pale, powdery residue marked one corner, and it carried a faint medicinal odor. Reed worked in commercial real-estate finance, and there was no reason for anything medicinal to be in the upstairs bathroom.

When I showed it to him, his expression did not change.

“Probably bath powder,” he said. “Maisie dumped half a container into the water last week.”

“We don’t own bath powder.”

He gave a small laugh and kissed my forehead.

“Then it’s soap. You’re analyzing a washcloth, Mara.”

The answer was reasonable enough to end the conversation, but not convincing enough to end my concern.

The Secret Game

The following evening, I told Reed that I would bathe Maisie.

He was standing at the kitchen counter, scrolling through his phone. At my suggestion, his thumb stopped moving.

“Why?”

“Because I miss having that time with her.”

His smile returned, though it seemed carefully arranged.

“She likes our routine. You know how she gets when things change.”

I watched him take her hand and lead her upstairs. Something in the firmness of his grip made my skin prickle.

Later, after he had gone to bed, I carried a cup of warm milk into Maisie’s room. She was sitting beneath her quilt with Juniper pressed against her chest.

I climbed onto the bed beside her.

“Can I ask you something about bath time?”

Her fingers tightened around the rabbit.

“Am I in trouble?”

“No. You are not in trouble, and you won’t be in trouble for telling me the truth.”

She lowered her eyes.

“What do you and Daddy do in there for so long?”

Her breathing changed. Tears gathered along her lower lashes, and she shook her head before I had asked anything more.

I reached for her hand but stopped when she pulled it close to her body.

“Maisie, look at me. Whatever happened, it isn’t your fault.”

For several seconds she said nothing. Then, in a voice so small that I almost missed it, she answered.

“Daddy says I can’t talk about the games in the bath.”